The Girl We Let In (2026) Cast & Crew

Overview · Where to watch · Cast & crew · Reviews

Directed by Ryan Callaway.

Cast

• Veronika Babina as Sophie Tatum
• Olivia Mignone as Hope Tatum
• Ryan Callaway as Jeremiah Tatum
• Clementine Benstock as Candace Tatum
• Winnie Penkethman as Brooke Castelli
• Sasha Pearson as Kayla Mitchell
• Hiram Ortiz as Dr. Simmons
• Denise Marie Whalen as Melissa Castelli
• Kailee McGuire as Ella Ingraham
• Adrian Espinal as Dexter
• Hannah Lemke as Brittany Etters

Crew

• Ryan Callaway — Director
• Ryan Callaway — Writer

Movies like The Girl We Let In

If you enjoyed The Girl We Let In, these movies have a similar feel:

• Z (2019)
• The Shed (2019)
• Strange but True (2019)
• Silent Zone (2025)
• Maniac (1963)
• Black Widow (1987)
• Race with the Devil (1975)
• What's the Matter with Helen? (1971)
• Chief of Station (2024)
• Nightfall (1956)
• The Man Who Cheated Himself (1950)
• Monkey’s Magic Merry Go Round (2026)

Can't decide what to watch?

FlickPicker recommends movies from your own taste and the services you subscribe to, and Pick Together lets a whole group vote on tonight's pick. Try the free random movie generator, find movies with AI, or browse trending movies.

Download FlickPicker on the App Store   Explore the iPhone app